Powered By IdeaScale
Login / Signup
Fcc.Gov About Open Internet Get Informed about the Open Internet and Open Internet Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) Read the Speech Workshops OpenInternet Blog Open Internet
« Back To OpenInternet.gov
Bill of Rights for the Open Internet
The Commission should establish a broadband “Bill of Rights” that will allow individual Americans and small organizations the basic right to broadcast and communicate over broadband. This Bill of Rights should include the following features:
1. All individual Internet stations have the right to broadcast and communicate over the Internet without interference by corporations and/or government.
2. Any charges or fees must be applied equally to users without favoritism.
3. If broadband usage exceeds existing capacity, usage can be rationed (in terms of bits per second) with all Internet users having the same proportional reduction in capacity for the duration of the shortage. There must be no favoritism at all for large organizations.
4. Government and/or private organizations may not monitor the content of Internet transmissions unless such monitoring is done by lawful court order. This will establish the appropriate privacy of Internet web casts, web sites, and email traffic.
5. First Amendment rights on the Internet shall be the same as the First Amendment rights for print and radio/TV broadcast media.
6. Intellectual property rights, such as copyright, shall be the same as the rights applying to print and radio/TV broadcast media.
7. All Internet station journalists and bloggers shall be recognized as legitimate journalists with the same rights of access as print or conventional broadcast station journalists.
8. The freedom of association and assembly shall apply to gatherings conducted on the Internet.

We must protect all Americans’ access to Internet broadcasting and all other uses of the Internet. This is basic to America’s democratic future.
Comments
Dar 1 month ago
How can a "Bill of Rights" require the government to limit our freedoms. That is an oxymoron. Government should not violate our liberties. The Bill of Rights in the Constitution itemizes a few of those.

These are all pretty silly but the best is #7. The idea of a "legitimate" journalist is not something that can be derived from the Bill of Rights. The first amendment does not license journalists.

We must protect our freedoms and not give in to people who want to control us and call it protecting rights.
knox52 1 month ago
I agree with leggett3's points about First Amendment rights, and the structure of having a "bill of rights" is appealing. But, on this point in the message...

3. If broadband usage exceeds existing capacity, usage can be rationed (in terms of bits per second) with all Internet users having the same proportional reduction in capacity for the duration of the shortage. There must be no favoritism at all for large organizations.

... this is not a workable concept. If you are in a capacity-constrained environment, it won't be favoritism for large corporations, but rather small users with "data hog" demands, that will bring down the network for everybody.

Large corporations are visible enough, and enough of a public target, for network management rules that will govern their behavior. Smaller users will be equally prone to bring down the Internet.

The concept of a "highway" is often used. The analogy here would be that ISPs build a highway, and then users can put out any number of trucks of any dimension (double-wides, tandems, triple-tandems) and if the highway gets clogged you sue the people who built the highway.

I hope that leggett3 can maybe re-think this point and have another try at the "Bill of Rights" concept!
Activity Chart
Controversy Meter
Idea Rank : 226
Share
RSS 
  • Users Tracking (1)