Reasonable Network Management

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

NO "management" or "data shaping" at all.

Packets should be treated like US mail. while they are in transit, they are sacred and their integrity is sacrosanct. Nobody, anywhere in the network, should have any right whatsoever to look at data, shape data, count data, or anything like that. Especially for the purposes of controlling it. the best way to accomplish this is to make sure there are absolutely no proprietary portions of the internet. right now huge ...more »

Submitted by (@dave.kliman)

Voting

169 votes
Active

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

Bandwidth caps should be illegal

No bandwidth caps and no unreasonable price increases. ISP's cap bandwidth not to save money, but to increase profits by charging people more for additional bandwidth. My friend works for an ISP and it cost the ISP next to nothing to provide you with service especially if the network is well used. The money you pay is almost entirely profits for the ISP. When an ISP caps bandwidth, it is a way to cause people to use ...more »

Submitted by (@inuyasha6332)

Voting

157 votes
Active

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

Do not regulate the creations of man

“If ye love wealth better than liberty, the tranquillity of servitude than the animating contest of freedom, — go from us in peace. We ask not your counsels or arms. Crouch down and lick the hands which feed you. May your chains sit lightly upon you, and may posterity forget that ye were our countrymen!” -Sam Adams The only FREE internet is an unregulated one. Regulation is domestication of the human mind. Stay free ...more »

Submitted by (@megsegg)

Voting

105 votes
Active

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

Private Companies Have Stolen Public Property

The issue is not the internet, the issue is the infrastructure. The 2oth century was characterised by the introduction of public utilities - massive investment in infrastructure that could only be justified if it was built once, not over and over. No one expects to have five sets of power lines run to their house so that five suppliers can compete - you would never get the first set of wires. To improve the life of the ...more »

Submitted by (@jeff.mcphate)

Voting

84 votes
Active

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

Don't regulate the Internet to death.

The existence of the Internet has provided the most open and accessible means of communication, idea sharing and expressive creativity that the world has ever seen. Introducing government regulation with all its bureaucracy and inefficiency would ultimately create more problems than the issues such policy would supposedly address.

Submitted by (@craig.england1)

Voting

45 votes
Active

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

Unlimited Internet - the foundation of growth

Fixed ISPs should not be allowed to charge based on usage, only on speed. Usage based ISPs only hinder internet company growth and technological progress. They create fear in the user that they might "overuse" their internet or do something that may cause their bill to rise. Unlimited internet providers, on the other hand, offer freedom, and the opportunity for capitalism to reign over the net.

Submitted by (@lando13)

Voting

28 votes
Active

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

Free and open Internet

If I were a Medical Doctor performing surgery on a patient with a very rare complicated problem and needed technical advice from another Doctor who happened to live in some small town in Russia, I should not have my request nor should he have his reply to my question held up by my ISP because Bank of America paid more for a priority line to transfer their data on. No corprate entity should ever be given the power to determine ...more »

Submitted by (@morrisocj)

Voting

23 votes
Active

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

A "Neutral Net" helps avoid issues with conflict of interest

When content providers are also the network providers the temptation to control the traffic to favor their own content is too great. The favoring of one's own content over another, and possibly competing, type of content is anticompetitive and limits the consumers ability to access the content of their choice. In many markets there is only one or two broadband access providers, which limits the consumers ability to switch ...more »

Submitted by (@rmichael511)

Voting

14 votes
Active

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

Regulate price and data caps, unlimited is best to serve all

Should regulate price, create lower cost, larger cap, plan restrictions, an unlimited plan was not out of the question a year ago and it should still be an option. Help us educate our children. Newspapers are a thing of the past now and internet is used for most communications and information including this one. I believe we need to look at price for data delivered especially since stimulus is paying for end of line and ...more »

Submitted by (@puzzledpurfact)

Voting

14 votes
Active

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

Advertisements use date too!

Advertisements use data too!

 

If the Broadband companies have their way and we all begin to get charged per MB usage, what are we going to do about all the advertisements that load on our pages? All that video, flash, or even text ads add up to a certain amount of data usage. We shouldn't have to use our monthly data allotment to load up some advertisement we never asked to see on our browser.

Submitted by (@myemail456)

Voting

10 votes
Active

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

Net is not neutral now

A large ISP (DSL provider) in California sells *their* VoIP service. If you order their VoIP service, all is well, quality is good, it works. If you DO NOT order their VoIP service, they sabotage your VoIP packets, you cannot use their DSL for voice service (another provider, or build-your-own). Basically, they implement a tiered service, or a $39 surcharge for the ability to use VoIP through their DSL. What next? ...more »

Submitted by (@taneli)

Voting

7 votes
Active

Campaign: Reasonable Network Management

Deeply Disappointed

I read on CNN the basics of the new FCC Internet plan, and was deeply disappointed. We need to move beyond the pothole patching. The last mile is still an issue, your hoping systems will have a 1 gig network card, and hope they can get to the library. The problem with Internet access is. 1. Too Expensive. 2. The Last mile is not the answer, cellular and broadband wi-fi is the answer. 3. Too narrowly focused in ...more »

Submitted by (@gmoore.mis)

Voting

-3 votes
Active