The Open Internet & the Freedom of Speech

Submitted by (@onaturalia)

No Government Regulation Enabling Network Hogs

Net Neutrality is about inhibiting network providers from controlling bandwidth hogs such as Google and other companies that wish to put huge amounts of data of the network that affect quality of service of all network customers. It penalizes network companies who work to prevent network outages and provide better service. I prevents you from using the Internet unemcumbered by bandwidth hogs. The network companies and ...more »

Voting

-101 votes
Active

The Open Internet & Innovation

Submitted by (@heroic)

The One Minute Case Against “Net Neutrality”

Advocates of “net neutrality” argue against the right of the owners of the pipes (Internet Service Providers) to discriminate between different messages or to charge recipients of messages. So for example, an ISP would not be able to favor telephone calls sent over the net over movie downloads, or charge Google extra for the traffic sent their way, or to block a business if it competes with their own services, or to block ...more »

Voting

-101 votes
Active

The Open Internet & Innovation

Submitted by (@pangasamaneesh)

Restore Net Neutrality protections and extend them to wireless

Net Neutrality is essential -- by the way we've had Net Neutrality before - it is the principle of an open democratic Internet where anyone can go online and connect freely with others (it is a principle to prevent ISPs from blocking online access to certain services) we had Net Neutrality prior to 2005 when the Bush FCC made the error of stripping the Internet of this basic protection for the Internet. Net Neutrality ...more »

Voting

-69 votes
Active

The Open Internet & the Freedom of Speech

Submitted by (@onaturalia)

Net Neutrality Stifles Innovation in the Network

Since I've posted my opposition to this idea of 'net neutrality' and the simple fact that it will throttle bandwidth by serving the few and remove the network providers ability to control quality of service and I'd like to respond. Response 1: Google pays for the network. Reply: Since when?? You pay for the network. Response 2: It does nothing to throttle network providers 'operating honestly'. Reply: Network providers ...more »

Voting

-37 votes
Active

The Open Internet & the Freedom of Speech

Submitted by (@ihy000)

Get this one right.

Internet network neutrality is absolutely *vital* to the burgeoning of free and open society not only here in the United States where I live, but all over the world, where free and open access to the Internet's wealth of information must be readily available for as many as possible. It is vital that corporations, those false "persons" who have in so many ways proven false to the real people, not be allowed to regulate ...more »

Voting

-10 votes
Active

Nondiscrimination

Submitted by (@matt00)

ISP's Can Not Be Allowed to Discriminate

The public needs FCC regulations to prevent Internet Service Providers from discriminating against some Internet traffic and favoring other traffic. My business and the Internet itself has flourished under the founding principle of Net Neutrality. Net Neutrality means that Internet Service Providers (ISP's) can not favor some Internet content over other content. For example, Comcast a large ISP, features streaming ...more »

Voting

-6 votes
Active

The Open Internet & Public Engagement

Submitted by

The utopia of net neutrality is an impossible goal to obtain.

Net neutrality is a perfect situation which will not be achievable. Sorry but there is no utopian ideal solution. The internet is like a lot of roadways and you have to allow authorities like the FCC and internet service providers to perform throttling, limits on total bandwidth use and modifications based upon access and ability to pay for excessive speeds so that the net can conduct its business reliably for the most ...more »

Voting

-1 votes
Active

Nondiscrimination

Submitted by (@aotsfan1)

The Debate so far, and a better solution than FCC regulation.

Since 2006 there has been a cycling debate over how the Internet should work. Should all data traveling over the network be treated about the same? Or, is Google getting a free lunch, and have its service degraded along with other ungrateful content providers abusing little old AT&T’s network (Buzz Out Loud 02/08/2006). The debate has changed since then from a hypothetical problem over “Google’s free lunch” (Buzz Out ...more »

Voting

1 vote
Active

The Open Internet & the Freedom of Speech

Submitted by (@jay0001)

Net Neutrality IS NOT a Neutral Net

There are many good ideas that are being brought forth here. Though I have my doubts as to the willingness of FCC officials to actually listen to a customer that they don't have to listen to. Who hires and runs the FCC? Who appoints FCC officials? What stake do they have in making and administering rules that govern communication and/or private sector businesses that provide communications tools? They do their master's ...more »

Voting

5 votes
Active

The Open Internet & the Freedom of Speech

Submitted by (@erikcorona)

What is a Gigabyte worth?

Internet Serivce Providers like ATT and COMCAST should stay the hell out of deciding if Gigabytes originating from Hulu servers or servers from their financial partners are worth more or less. Let them charge us for BANDWIDTH. I don't want some greedy corporate executive looking to maximize profits deciding that I need to pay more for one Gigabyte over another. They are the same. Once Internet Service Providers get this ...more »

Voting

7 votes
Active

The Open Internet & the Freedom of Speech

Submitted by (@kristinapole)

What do we really want?

What do we really want the government to be involved in? We can agree, its made a mess of Afghanistan, and should stay out of Iran. The debate over healthcare rages, but I think its agreed that education is a mess, immigration is apathetic, and drug patrols are inefficient to say the least. And now we want them involved in regulating the internet? I agree, the internet should stay neutral, and that freedom of speech ...more »

Voting

8 votes
Active

The Open Internet & Innovation

Submitted by (@notsunil)

1 step forward, 2 steps back.

Net Neutrality or an open internet is a vital part of what the internet is about. It's because of those principals that we have had the innovation that the Internet "Freedom" Act supposedly likes. The only reason we haven't needed a net neutrality law in place so far, is because the ISPs are scared that if they push too hard and too fast, that such a law will definitely come into place. So they've been doing it slowly ...more »

Voting

58 votes
Active